🪙 $1,700 for a $100 Box? Why 2024 Jefferson Nickels Are Selling for INSANE Prices

$1,700 for a $100 Box?

Most people walk into a bank, grab a box of nickels, and think nothing of it. But what if I told you that some $100 boxes of 2024 Jefferson nickels are selling for up to $1,700? 😲

Yes — these are not ordinary nickel rolls.

Let’s break down why collectors are paying big money, how you can search for them, and what makes certain 2024 nickels extremely valuable.

🔍 Step 1: Understand What a Nickel Box Is

A standard bank box of nickels contains:

💵 $100 face value
📦 50 rolls
🪙 2,000 nickels total

Normally, boxes contain mixed dates. But if you’re lucky enough to find a box full of 2024 nickels, you may have something special.

👉 One such box reportedly sold for $1,675 after 15 bids — turning $100 into serious profit.

📉 Step 2: The Real Reason 2024 Nickels Are Valuable

The key is low mintage.

Compared to recent years:

2023-P Nickels: ~692 million minted
2023-D Nickels: ~734 million minted

Now look at 2024:

✅ 2024-P Nickels: ~79 million minted
✅ 2024-D Nickels: ~33 million minted

That’s almost 10 times fewer coins than previous years!

Low supply + high collector demand = higher prices.

🏛️ Step 3: Look for P and D Mint Marks

When checking nickels:

🔵 P = Philadelphia Mint
🔴 D = Denver Mint

These are the coins you can realistically find in circulation. Proof coins (S mint) are made for collectors and are not usually found in bank rolls.

🌟 Step 4: What Are “Full Steps” and Why They Matter

On the reverse of a Jefferson nickel, Monticello has steps.

If all steps are clearly visible and uninterrupted, the coin earns the designation:

👉 Full Steps (FS)

Coins with Full Steps are much rarer and far more valuable.

💎 Step 5: Real Sold Prices (Graded Coins)

Here are actual examples of what collectors have paid:

🥇 2024-D MS68 Full Steps (NGC): ~$1,700
🥈 2024-P MS68 Full Steps (PCGS): Best offer accepted
🥉 2024-D MS67 Full Steps: ~$249
📊 Many MS67–MS68 examples: $175–$300

Higher grade = higher value.

💰 Step 6: Ungraded Coins Still Sell Well

Even raw (ungraded) coins are bringing premiums:

🪙 Two rolls ($4 face value): Sold for $58
🪙 Two single 2024 nickels: Sold for $1.93

Not bad for 10 cents!

📊 Step 7: Population Reports Explain the Big Prices

Grading companies track how many coins exist at each grade:

2024-P Nickels (PCGS)

MS66: 239 coins
MS67: 98 coins
MS68 Full Steps: Only 8 coins

2024-D Nickels (PCGS)

MS67: 23 coins
MS68 Full Steps: None reported
MS68 Full Steps Prooflike: Only 1 coin

This extreme rarity at top grades is why prices explode.

⚠️ Step 8: Know the Risk of Grading

Grading costs money. If your coin comes back MS66 or MS67, it may only be worth $10–$60.

But if you hit:

👉 MS68 Full Steps
You could be holding a $1,000–$1,700 coin.

It’s a gamble — but one with huge upside.

🏦 Step 9: How to Start Searching

Visit your local bank
Ask for a box of nickels
Search for 2024 P & D mint marks
Inspect for sharp details and Full Steps
Consider professional grading for the best coins

🚀 Final Thoughts

2024 Jefferson nickels are one of the most exciting modern coin finds right now. Their low mintage, combined with scarcity in high grades, makes them a hot target for collectors.

That $100 box from the bank could be your next big win. 🪙💥